Meeting Details
February 16, 2023
6:30pm
Coshocton City Schools - Coshocton Elementary School, 1203 Cambridge Rd., Coshocton OH
Purpose
N/A
Minutes
The meeting was called to order at 6:30 p.m.
Resolution: 019-2023
Minutes
The Pledge of Allegiance was recited.
Coshocton City Schools, in partnership with families and community, will empower individuals to become literate, respectful, responsible, and independent lifelong learners in an ever-changing global society.
Minutes
The Mission Statement was read by Mr. Sam Bennett.
Minutes
Dr. Jere Butcher was absent from this meeting. All other Board members were in attendance.
It is recommended that the Board of Education adopt the agenda.
Minutes
The Board members approved the Agenda and the Addendum that was presented prior to the start of the meeting.
Resolution: 020-2023
Motioned: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Seconded: Mr. David Shutt, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the Superintendent's Resignation.
Minutes
Dr. Hire read his letter of resignation aloud to the Board and all in attendance. When he finished, Mr. Phil Hunt called for a vote to approve the Superintendent's Resignation.
Resolution: 021-2023
Result: Approved
Motioned: Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President
Seconded: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following meeting minutes:
Minutes
The vote on this item is inclusive of items 7.1 through 7.3.
Resolution: 022-2023
Motioned: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Seconded: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
January 4, 2023 Special Meeting Minutes
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on item 7.0.
Resolution: 022.1-2023
Result: Approved
January 12, 2023 Tax Budget Hearing and Organizational Meeting Minutes
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on item 7.0.
Resolution: 022.2-2023
Result: Approved
January 12, 2023 Regular Meeting Minutes
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on item 7.0.
Resolution: 022.3-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education enter into Executive Session to consider the investigation of charges or complaints against a public employee, official, licensee, or student.
Minutes
The Board voted to enter into an executive session at 6:35 p.m
The Board exited the executive session and resumed the meeting at 7:37 p.m.
Resolution: 023-2023
Result: Approved
Motioned: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Seconded: Mr. David Shutt, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
This meeting is a meeting of the Board of Education in public for the purpose of conducting the School District’s business and is not to be considered a public community meeting. In order for the Coshocton City School Board of Education to conduct its meetings in a productive and efficient manner that assures that the regular agenda of the Board is completed in a reasonable period of time, a maximum of thirty minutes of public participation will be permitted at each regular meeting, unless extended by a vote of the Board. Any person or group wishing to address the Board shall register their intent to participate upon their arrival at the meeting. All statements should be addressed to the presiding officer. The Board retains the right to table any matter until further study can be made. Each participant addressing the Board will give his/her name, address, and group affiliation, and shall be limited to three-minutes duration.
Minutes
Peter Wolfgang requested to address the Board at the start of the meeting by completing a request form. Mr. Hunt informed Mr. Wolfgang that he was welcome to come forward and begin his presentation.
Mr. Wolfgang introduced himself and shared that he was a Coshocton High School 1999 graduate and provided a brief summary of his history since then. He began his presentation by discussing the children today and his concern about the difference in morals and ethics today among kids from when he was a kid and brought up in this community and shared his concern about the relation of this to technology today. He proceeded to explain his intent for speaking to the Board was to ask if the board has ever considered "Release Time." He went on to explain that "Release Time" was passed into law in 2014. He explained that it allows for children to have religion-based education during the school day, off school property. The way it works is that students are released for a period of time, maybe 25-30 minutes. No taxpayer resources are allowed to be used. He stated that he is currently working with students at River View right now. He will meet with River View's Superintendent tomorrow morning to discuss expanding the program to the high school level. His current students are at the elementary level and he would like to move into the high school level where some students may be able to get up to two(2) credits for doing an independent study, possibly through History class. He added that with this program, he can work with the students on projects that could possibly be Bible related. He had a copy of the Bill and stated that it was only a couple of pages long. He said all he asking right now is that the Board members consider it and he would come back at a later time, maybe at the next meeting, to have more discussion about this. He did not leave a copy of the Bill for the Board.
Minutes
Josh Predovich, with SHP, was present at the meeting and Kevin Back, with SHP, was on Zoom. Josh opened the presentation with a brief update on the Facility Master Planning with the community stating that the Community Advisory Team (CAT) had their first Community Advisory Team meeting, after the two community presentations and community surveys, on February 13, 2023. Their next scheduled meeting is scheduled for March 20, 2023. Josh explained that the goal of the survey is to gather as much information as we can on the questions asked to the community. Josh will be working with Jacob to get an update on the projects that have been completed at the High School as well as any issues or concerns that may have surfaced since the original planning phase of the master plan process. He mentioned the public presentations and stated that it would be appropriate to also have staff presentations. He is working on scheduling and will try to schedule those meetings before March 20th. His summary report from the last CAT was that we spent time reviewing all of the options, listened to survey results with the community input, and had discussions. The general report, at this time, is that the team seems to be narrowing the options down to two - the new 7-12 building or the renovation of the HS with OFCC support. Josh stated that we not only want to engage the community in this process, but we also want to get as much of the staff engaged as we possibly can.
Josh then introduced Kevin Back to provide the results of the second survey. Kevin opened by stating that it is clear that the community is not just going for the least expensive master plan option. They are reading, understanding and evaluating the information they are receiving and determining what they think is the best option for the District. Kevin then began sharing the results of the 2nd survey. Kevin then informed the board that there were fewer responses to the second survey with 581 responses. He also assured the Board that this calculated a 4% margin of error, statistically, which makes the responses acceptable and validates the results of the survey and that this is an acceptable representation of the community. The District used the same resources to spread the news to the community for the second survey as they did with the first survey. He then stated that the general overall takeaway from the survey responses is that out of the 4 options and the 2 “sub” options, there were two options that had the most positive responses. The responses to the questions showed that the majority of responses came from parents; the majority were in the 30-44 age range; the majority have lived in the district for over 20 years; and the majority are professionals. Kevin also pointed out that on the first survey, there were 80 student responses. This increased on the second survey to 88 student responses. Questions 5-10 asked about Master Plan options. The scores were tallied on a weighted average and out of all of the options, we are starting to see two options most popular with the community. Build a new 7th-12 building being the most popular, and Renovate the HS being next. He stated that there were many comments submitted on the survey with a good number of them sharing concerns for the community spaces – pool, auditorium, planetarium, and gym - if a new building were to be the final decision. Kevin summarized the findings by sharing that the responses from both surveys show that this is important to the community. Josh then added that the Community Advisory Team and the District communicating the details of the options is important and they are part of the development of the plan decision. He asked the Board if any of them had questions. Mr. Phil Hunt asked about the time of the next CAT meeting. The time is 6:00 p.m. on March 20th. Josh said he is leaving a copy of the survey results and comments and that Kevin will provide a copy of the PowerPoint and the detailed information. They thanked the Board for the opportunity to present the results tonight.
Minutes
Mr. Casey shared a PowerPoint presentation that showcased some of the activities the staff and students have participated in this year and shared accomplishments. He stated how proud he was of all of the staff and students. Mr. Casey’s presentation began with sharing information about the two 5th-grade college trips to Muskingum and C Tec. He shared that while at C Tec, students had the opportunity to dress up as firefighters. They also took an assessment that told them about optional career paths they may excel in as an adult. The students found this fun and some results were professions the students had never even thought of. He shared that the students created Goodie Boxes for Coshocton Graduates that are College freshmen or in the military, writing personal letters to each and packing goodies in the box. This experience gives some of our graduates a chance to come back and share with our students what college life is like. Mr. Casey also shared changes implemented in the way Title students were served this year and the great progress students are making as a result of the new intervention strategies. Mrs. Mann asked if this was just 3-6 or building-wide. Mr. Casey said it was building-wide. Mr. Casey stated how proud he is of the students that participated in the Writing contests this year – 6th graders wrote about American Dream. Coshocton won all top 3 honors. And Coshocton had the highest student representation at the Zane Trace Contest. Young Coshocton students were recognized for their participation. Mr. Casey also shared that the teachers had a new curriculum to implement this year. Feedback from the teachers showed that they needed additional time to collaborate and work on the new curriculum, and prepare lessons. Feedback from the staff has been positive. Hearing that, the administration decided to do it again because it is important, helpful, and appreciated by our teachers. He shared that the 4th-grade program this year honored veterans. Those that were in the military were honored at the program. Upcoming programs are – the 3rd-grade program coming up on March 7, and the 5th-grade program will also be coming up. Not in the PowerPoint, but definitely proud and excited. is that 5-12 choir members will be singing the National Anthem on May 13 at a Cleveland Game; the 5th graders that play will be going to Kent State Theatre to perform with other districts in an orchestra. He then talked about the students that presented goodie bags and caroled at Signature Healthcare. He discussed the LTRS training in-service for staff working on a new program in kindergarten and the realizations that the group came to as a result of it. He closed with information about the GEARS program – 38 students participate in the AM; they have breakfast and then go to class. The afternoon GEARS serves 62 students at this time. There are many educational hands-on activities, games, and homework time. This is run by Tammy Jacobs. The final announcement is that Chili Supper coming up on March 5-7th. Tickets are available now. He stated that this is not a money maker, the cost of the ticket is to cover costs only. The cost is $10 per family or $2 per person. Tickets will be sold at door. Mr. Casey reiterated how proud he is of the staff and the students and thanked the Board for allowing him to be the leader of grades 3-6. There were no questions from the Board.
Minutes
Mr. Todd Johnson thanked the Board for allowing him to serve in the Special Education Director role at Coshocton CSD. He shared the attached document with the Board that contained historical data. He explained that the information at the top was the data that made up the diagram below. He then went on to explain that in Special Education there are 16 categories for the last 4 years and said that there were not a large number of changes from last year to this year. He stated that the largest population of Special Education students in our district are speech and language. He pointed out the percentage at bottom is similar to this year. The number of students on 504 plans last year was very similar to the number this year. Specific Learning dropped from 35% last year to 31% this year. The breakdown by grade level was presented. Speech ET 05 wanted to make note of that. It has increased dramatically from 7 to 17 PS students. Last year the increase was from 7 to 17. Partly, this is due to many students in early intervention, help me grow, and other places outside district. Students are being referred sooner. Not nearly as many referred last year. We have been able to address and keep on track pretty early this year. Mr. Johnson took time to recognize everyone that has stepped up during this very challenging year to help him and help the children.
The chart a the bottom showed placements out, foster and open enrolled Special Education students increased. He pointed out that Sacred heart numbers increased this year and that we have no students on scholarship out. We are obligated to notify parents of John Peterson and Autism Scholarship which provides parent choice if they do not want public school. If they have one of the eligible disabilities, they can go to private school and a scholarship can help pay for services they would get in public school
Mr. Johnson asked the Board if they had questions after reviewing the document - there were none. Mr. Johnson took time to give recognition to intervention staff in our schools. It has been a difficult year for them. He commended all Intervention Specialists that stepped up to alleviate overload. He appreciates all they did to help through the process and wanted to make sure the Board was aware and appreciated that as well.
After a detailed review of all items on the attachment, Mr. Johnson asked again if there were any questions or concerns related to the document that had Special Education numbers and services provided.
Minutes
Mrs. Mann mentioned that she had a couple of topics to discuss. First was the school calendar. She stated that Dr. Hire said there would be a committee. Mrs. Mann has had concerns brought to her about trying to align our calendars to Riverview and Ridgewood. She stated that some of our teachers have children that attend these schools and it would be nice if they would run similar calendars.
Mrs. Mann's second topic was substitute issues that she wants to share. She stated that the question keeps coming to her so she is bringing it here. Do we have subs? If we do, where are they? She is specifically concerned that the Title staff is being pulled every day to sub. The Title staff shared shocking information showing that this year they have subbed 109 partial and/or full days. Immediately in her mind, she thought "well there are 109 struggling readers that are not being provided with services, adding that this is concerning to her. She asked - where is the problem with subbing, we have a list - why are they not subbing. Are they not wanting to? Is the process too cumbersome? It is concerning to her that it has been a year since Jen Spang came to talk with the Board and a year later we still have the same problem. We need to look at other options and keep this problem first and foremost. Is Rachel Wixey our best option?
Mr. Bennett asked if other districts are having the same problem we are. Dr. Hire provided a report with numbers - The job fair sheet showed the SB1 subs - these are subs without a college degree. We have 13 so far and 5 more are in the process. Some put several districts on their list and they can get picked up for long-term positions in another district.
Mrs. Mann put in a plug for her "Title friends" saying they told her they are tired. One stated that her anxiety is so high that she doesn't want to go to school anymore. Mrs. Mann said that we don't want that, we need every teacher to want to come to school each day. In some situations, teachers can combine classes. She would like to see us look at other options.
Mr. Hunt asked about other agencies in the area. Does Rachel Wixey call for subs, are they supposed to call for subs? Ms. Eyerman stated that if the staff puts their absence in early enough, the FrontlLIne system calls for subs.
Ms. Eyerman stated that she will work with Lonie and together they can call other districts to see what they are using, and what is the situation with those companies. Are these districts having the same concerns?
Mrs. Mann stated that she keeps hearing that the paperwork process is too much. Ms. Eyerman explained that if an interested person calls the Board office and talks to Lonie or me, we fast-track it. Becky and Vikki are trained to complete the documents that need to be witnessed. She stated that her concern was heard in prior meetings so we reached out to Rachel Wixey to come up with ways we can streamline the process as best we can.
Mrs. Mann shared that one person from out of state wants to start subbing, she looked on our Website and could not locate anything specific about what to do or any instructions to contact the Board office. Ms. Eyerman stated that she would talk to Jason to ensure that more prominent instructions are on the website.
A year ago we raised our rates to be above other surrounding districts. Dr. Hire wanted to be sure to update the board because as soon as we have someone call we push it through - regular people out there are not applying to be a sub. We have 13 and may be able to have 18.
Mrs. Mann stated that As she looked at the list Dr. Hire provided from the Superintendent update attachment, we have people that subbed 3 times last year and this year not at all. Have we reached out to them Why haven't they been back?
Dr. Hire stated that we will try to reach out to those to see why.
Mrs. Mann stated again that she would like to have it front and center on the website
Dr. Hire reminded the board that all districts are competing for the same subs. Subs can state where they want to sub. once they choose districts and go there. He has had Superintendent meetings with other districts. They need to recruit and when they talk to Rachel Wixey, they use Coshocton CSD as a poster child explaining what we are doing to recruit, advertise, etc. He did state that we had the option to hire our own subs.
Mr. Hunt stated that we are dealing with an odd job market right now. He cannot get applicants to call him back.
Dr. Hire stated that we have had applicants apply to us, we call Rachel Wixey to push their applications through, then when we call them, they never call back. He also shared that he has heard concerns that Rachel Wixey is making too much money. Dr. Hire explained that the substitute receives the daily rate we pay. Rachel Wixey gets a premium but that is outside of the sub pay and that is not subtracted from the subs daily rate.
It is recommended that the Board of Education enter into an executive session to consider the employment of a public employee.
Minutes
this needs to be 13.1 The Board voted to enter into an executive session at 8:37 p.m
The Board exited the executive session and resumed the meeting at 8:49 p.m.
Resolution: 024-2023
Result: Approved
Motioned: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Seconded: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following items:
Minutes
The vote on this item is inclusive of times 13.2-13.4.
Resolution: 025-2023
Motioned: Mr. David Shutt, Board Member
Seconded: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
Insurance Fund (024) Update
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the January Monthly Financial Summary.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Ms. Eyerman stated that the District is on target on most budget lines year to date and called attention to a few items in the monthly report that appeared not to be on target and explained why and what to expect.
Mr. Hunt asked if the District would be looking into the purchase of electric school buses. He had read about possible grants and asked if we were going to get money to buy any and if so, do we get money for service and charging stations too. Ms. Eyerman explained that we have had opportunities early on. Jake attended meetings to learn more. At that time he was not a proponent and was concerned about the cost to replace the batteries being as much as purchasing a new bus. We have continued to have more conversations. There will be more grants. Jake is looking into the infrastructure. Dr. Hire said Grant did some of this work last year. Dr. Hire thinks with our size, we would be in a good position to try one if a grant is available. Ms. Eyerman stated there are so many changes and improvements with the batteries and performance and we continue to have an interest.
Resolution: 025.1-2023
Result: Approved
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Ms. Eyerman expressed appreciation for the donors and their donations.
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the creation of a student activity account for the Class of 2029 - Fund Number 300-9129.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 13.0
Ms. Eyerman stated that in future years the plan is to add the new class accounts to the agenda at the beginning of the school year.
Resolution: 025.4-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following business items:
Minutes
The vote on this item is inclusive of times 14.1-14.4.
Resolution: 026-2023
Motioned: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Seconded: Mr. David Shutt, Board Member
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the College Credit Plus Memorandum of Understanding with Kent State University for the 2023-2024 school year.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Dr. Hire stated that this is the time of year that these agreements are put into place for the next year's College Credit Plus Program. It is possible that there could be more agreements and if there are they will be added to the agenda for approval.
Resolution: 026.1-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the College Credit Plus Memorandum of Understanding with Stark State College for the 2023-2024 school year.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Resolution: 026.2-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the College Credit Plus Memorandum of Understanding and Data Sharing Agreement with Zane State College for the 2023-2024 school year.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Resolution: 026.3-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the Bilateral Articulation Agreement with Zane State College for 2023 to 2026 graduates.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 14.0.
Resolution: 026.4-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following items:
Minutes
The vote on this item is inclusive of times 15.2-15.6.
Resolution: 027-2023
Motioned: Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President
Seconded: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |
Minutes
The substitute teacher update took place during Item # 11- Board Discussion.
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the following personnel items pending required paperwork, licensure, and BCI/FBI Background checks. Salary placement is per the negotiated agreement subject to verification of degree and experience:
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 15.0.
Dr. Hire mentioned that Jacob Conrad has finished the interview process for a replacement for his past position. The new hire will be able to handle the mechanic side of the job and will learn all of the building side.
Dr. Hire wished Valerie Dawson well and explained that Jeri Dawson's previous position was split between bus driver and food service and will that she will now move into the Head Cook position. After explaining the process of hiring replacements for Jeri's past position, he continued to review the list of personnel items listed.
Resolution: 027.1-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education accept and approve the Interdistrict Open Enrollment Policy and Application for for the 2023-2024 school year.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 15.0.
Dr. Hire shared that this is an annual process and that the District looks at grade level counts to see if we have to limit open enrollment at any grade levels.
Resolution: 027.2-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve the 2023-2024 Coshocton High School Course Catalog as submitted by Scott Loomis, Principal.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 15.0.
Dr. Hire explained that approval of the course catalog is an item necessary for the HS to begin the scheduling process. He also explained a change this year stating that there are some courses that are offered every other year. Instead of leaving the courses out on the year they are not being offered and then putting them back in when they are, it has been decided that these courses will remain in the catalog but state if the current year is the year it is offered or not. This will ensure that the courses do not appear to be new course offerings every time they show up in the catalog.
Resolution: 027.3-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve an overnight field trip for the Wrestling Team to attend the State Wrestling Match at Ohio State University on March 10-12, 2023, coordinated by Sean Collins, Wrestling Head Coach.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 15.0.
Resolution: 027.4-2023
Result: Approved
It is recommended that the Board of Education approve an overnight field trip for the Swim Team to attend the Varsity District Swimming Meet at Ohio State University on February 15-16, 2023, coordinated by Kris King, Swimming Head Coach.
Minutes
The vote for this item is recorded on 15.0.
Resolution: 027.5-2023
Result: Approved
Minutes
Dr. Hire shared the Great Things To Know In February 2023.
Regular Meeting - Thursday, March 23, 2023 at 6:30 p.m. in the Coshocton Elementary School Library.
Special Meeting -
Minutes
Ms. Terri Eyerman requested that the Board schedule a Special Meeting to discuss the updates to the District's property repairs and upgrades list and schedule as well as review maintenance plans for summer work on scheduled items. Other items may be discussed as needed. After a discussion of available times, a Special Meeting was planned for March 15 from 3:30-5:00 p.m. at the Board office.
It is recommended that the Board of Education adjourn the meeting.
Minutes
The meeting was adjourned at 9:16 p.m.
Resolution: 028-2023
Result: Approved
Motioned: Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member
Seconded: Mr. Phil Hunt, President
Voter | Yes | No | Abstaining |
---|---|---|---|
Mr. David Shutt, Board Member | X | ||
Mr. Sam Bennett, Vice-President | X | ||
Dr. Jere Butcher, Board Member | |||
Mr. Phil Hunt, President | X | ||
Mrs. Susan Mann, Board Member | X |